Collaborate with Mark āœ…

Collaborate with Mark āœ…

šŸ”’Leader's Dispatch: The Great Dashboard šŸ“Š Delusion—A Crisis ⚔Leaders Can’t Escape!

Leader's Dispatch Volume 8

Mark S. Carroll āœ…'s avatar
Mark S. Carroll āœ…
Sep 08, 2025
āˆ™ Paid
1
Share

Top of the Series: šŸ”’Leader's Dispatch: Has OpenAI Lost Its Strategic Edge? (Windsurf AI ā˜¢ļøFallout🧨)

Previous: šŸ”’Leader's Dispatch: The Illusion of Infinite Scale

Leader’s Dispatch: The Cult of Metrics — Why Dashboards Don’t Equal Decisions

Opening Cutscene

Prologue Quest: Enter Dashlytics Unlimitedā„¢

Dashlytics Unlimitedā„¢ promised leaders total clarity, unveiling 147 dashboards to track every heartbeat of the business, but the team spent more time staring at charts than serving customers (This is a fictional company, a composite of many real ones that confuse dashboards for decisions).


Executives celebrated record-high KPI alignment, but no one noticed revenue slipping quietly quarter after quarter.


Managers declared, ā€œIf it’s on a dashboard, it must be true,ā€ but customer complaints piled up in inboxes no graph displayed.


They hosted a quarterly ā€œData Summitā€ to honor their charts with champagne toasts, but every big decision still stalled in analysis paralysis.


Therefore, Dashlytics Unlimitedā„¢ didn’t scale insight at all—it just scaled noise, proving that measuring everything means learning nothing.

ā€œWe’ve never had more dashboards — or less clarity.ā€


The Lore: Why Metrics Have Become a Cult

The Backstory: How Dashboards Took the Throne

  • Leaders are drowning in dashboards (every SaaS tool adds 10 more).

  • The myth: more data = better decisions.

  • Reality: overload leads to decision paralysis, misaligned incentives, and eroded trust.

  • Callback: ties to Vol. 7 (Infinite Scale), where dashboards were confused with relationships.

Pull Quote: ā€œWe’ve never had more dashboards — or less clarity.ā€


Archetypes: How Leaders Fall into the Cult

Every cult has its high priests, and the Cult of Metrics is no exception. At Dashlytics Unlimitedā„¢, they weren’t villains so much as archetypes—characters you’ll recognize in any org that worships dashboards more than decisions.

šŸ”® The Metric Magician
He dazzles with endless charts, waving his wand like every graph is a spell of insight. His favorite incantation? ā€œIf the numbers go up, we must be winning!ā€ Yet when you look closer, his power comes from vanity metrics—slides per quarter, meetings scheduled—not actual outcomes. The audience claps, the charts glow, but customers keep slipping away.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Collaborate with Mark āœ… to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Ā© 2025 Mark S. Carroll
Privacy āˆ™ Terms āˆ™ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture